Can You Win a Clerk Magistrate Hearing?

Yes—and winning means the complaint never issues.

A Clerk Magistrate hearing isn’t about guilt or innocence. It’s about whether there’s *probable cause* to believe a crime occurred. That’s a low standard, but it’s not automatic. With the right strategy, many people succeed in getting the case dismissed before it even begins.

Some common ways to win:
- Pointing out inconsistencies or lack of evidence in the complaint.
- Showing that the alleged conduct wasn’t actually a crime.
- Presenting mitigation or context that persuades the clerk not to issue.
- Working out a resolution with the police or complainant before or during the hearing.

Winning a Clerk Magistrate hearing means avoiding an arraignment, a criminal record, and public court involvement. These hearings are a unique opportunity in Massachusetts criminal practice—and one of the most important chances you’ll get to stop a case early.

If you’ve received a notice for a clerk hearing, take it seriously, and contact me.